Advice to writers: your first novel

Chuck it.

That’s right – throw it away. The odds are ten to one (or worse) that it will ever be published. And yes, I do know that advice is going to hurt…

I admire anyone who actually finishes a book. It’s not a simple undertaking – it requires perseverance and sacrifice. It’s time you could have spent with your family, or watching TV, or reading, or something else just as attractive. You had the required strength of character, and you finished. And now you want the world to know the result and love it the way you do.

Sometimes it even happens. I personally do know people who did have their very first book published and it has turned out to be very successful too, the start of a prosperous career. However, it is a rare occurrence, believe me. When you press most successful authors for the truth, you will find that most of them threw the first effort away, or never showed it to anyone, or never finished it.

The truth is that no tennis player gets to Wimbleton centre court first time out; no golfer wins the Masters first time around. What you don’t see is the years and years of practice that gets them to that point. Remember those hours and hours of piano practice you did as a kid? Or the band practice in the garage, or the guitar practice in your bedroom with the door shut? Your first book is that practice. And possibly so is your second, third and fourth.

Some of you are now muttering, “No one is that stupid. Write four or five books and never get any published? They should have given up! And if they did do that and weren’t published, they are obviously crap writers and idiots to boot…”

Hey, wait a moment. That’s me you’re talking about. I may be an idiot, but I’m not a crap writer. And I have been published – in five countries and three languages. I now have seven books published or on their way to publication. I’ve been shortlisted for awards. Yet my path to success is littered with unpublished manuscripts – and I’ve lost count of how many.

I finished my first novel when I was twelve, my second and third when I was in my twenties, and so on. Some I never showed anyone at all. Others were read by friends. Most I sent off just the once or twice and then gave up when they were rejected – not knowing how precious the words of encouragement I received were. (I truly was an innocent abroad…)

My advice is: don’t put all your hopes in your first effort. In fact, think very carefully about marketing it at all. Writing is a lifetime career, and you have to learn your craft first. When you have finished your first book, start immediately on the second. You can always come back to that first one again later, and either mine it for ideas, or rewrite it with a new outlook in a few years time.

Daunting? Yes. The question is this: just how much do you want to be a published writer? Are you in it for the long haul? If you know you will write no matter what, then an unpublished MS, or two, or three, is nothing. They were fun to write, after all, weren’t they?

Remember Ursula LeGuin? Asked what she would have been if she hadn’t been a writer, she replied: “Dead.” Well, that’s me, too. And most other writers worth their salt. This is not just a job we do for money, it’s a drive we have to create. It’s the journey that counts. Remember van Gogh? The only paintings he ever sold in his lifetime were to his brother. It didn’t stop him from painting.

So my advice is : Write. Keep on writing. Learn your craft, and one day you’ll probably get there. But don’t, don’t, get too hung up on the fate of your first book. After all, you were just practising…


Advice to writers: your first novel — 7 Comments

  1. Glenda, there no way I’m going to throw out my first novel! I love it too much. Every now and then, I go back and read it and still enjoy it, even though I shudder at some of the faux pas.

    The poor thing will probably never be seen between cardboard cover with piccies on, because it’s very definitely a practice piece. Maybe one day I’ll revise it and send it out, but in the meantime I’m busy writing three more novels. More practice…

  2. Satima, I don’t think I would have the courage to even peek at my very first novel It would be too embarrassing!

  3. Every book is your first book. I HATE everything I write, because it could have been better. “Art is never finished” someone once said that. If I had a chance, I’d spend my entire life on one book, and it would still not have been finished. So everytime I read something I wrote, I see all the mistakes that I could have fixed, I see all the things that I would have done differently but was outvoted by marketing and editing and others. It’s all crap. I’m just writing ‘cos well, as she says, otherwise I’d be dead. It pays the bills, and other people seem to like reading it. Other than that, it’s crap.

    So how long do you take to write a book, and how do you survive in the meantime ?

  4. I wish I’d had this advice before I sent the first draft of my first novel off to agents with the dream I’d be famous in 12 months. I am very grateful that they didn’t actually laugh in my face but rejected me very gracefully.

  5. We all have those moments, Anon, of thinking it’s crap. But don’t you also have those moments of thinking – hey, wow, did I write this? That’s not so bad!

    It takes me about a year to write a book, if you include alterations after my editor’s and copy ediitor’s input.

    How do I survive? You just do what you have to – write. I also have another job which involves something totally different: getting out in the field.

    Keep trying Nicole, for as long as you enjoy what you are doing.

Leave a Reply to Glenda Larke Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.